Spearing in football refers to a dangerous tackling practice where a player leads with their helmet in an attempt to hit an opponent, often in the torso or head area. This move involves a player lowering their head and using the helmet as the primary point of contact. It’s a method that’s not only illegal but also highly risky, as it can lead to severe injuries for both the tackler and the player being tackled. Football governing bodies penalize spearing to protect players and maintain a safer game.
The dangers associated with spearing have led to strict rules against it at all levels of football—from high school to the NFL. Understanding these rules is crucial for players, coaches, and fans who want to see the game played safely and fairly.
1. What is Spearing in Football?
Spearing is defined as a tackling technique in which a player leads with the top of their helmet to make contact. This technique is especially dangerous because it forces the tackler’s neck and spine into a compressed position, which increases the risk of serious injuries, such as:
Head and Neck Injuries : Spearing exposes both players to head and neck trauma, including concussions, fractured vertebrae, and even paralysis.
Spinal Injuries : By leading with the helmet, a player risks spinal cord injuries due to the direct force on the neck and back.
Risk to Opponents : Not only does spearing endanger the tackler, but it also places the opponent at risk for traumatic injuries, especially when targeting areas like the chest or head.
This method of tackling goes against the principles of safe play, making it an unacceptable and dangerous approach. With heightened awareness around the long-term impact of football injuries, spearing is taken very seriously by officials and coaches alike.
Decrease Opponent Points by 18.1% with Atavus
Enhance defense and player safety through data-driven tackle training.
In football, the rules against spearing are strictly enforced to ensure player safety, as spearing is widely regarded as one of the most dangerous forms of tackling. Governing bodies like the NFHS, NCAA, and NFL have established clear guidelines and penalties to discourage players from leading with the helmet. Below is an in-depth look at how each level of football handles spearing and why these rules are crucial for a safer game.
High School Football
The National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) includes spearing as a prohibited act under its “Illegal Helmet Contact” rules. For high school players, spearing can lead to significant penalties, including:
15-Yard Penalty : If a player is caught leading with the helmet, their team may receive a 15-yard penalty, pushing them back and potentially costing them field position and momentum.
Player Ejection : In cases where the spearing act is especially dangerous or repeated, the player may be ejected from the game. Ejections serve as a strict deterrent and emphasize that spearing is not tolerated.
At the high school level, the rules against spearing are particularly important because players are still developing their skills and learning the fundamentals of safe tackling. Coaches play a vital role in teaching these young athletes proper techniques to avoid penalties, injuries, and ejections. Additionally, high school athletic programs often emphasize education on the risks associated with head injuries, which helps to instill safe practices in players from a young age.
College Football
At the college level, spearing is also prohibited and closely monitored. The NCAA rules classify spearing as part of “targeting” violations, which aim to protect defenseless players from dangerous hits, particularly to the head and neck area. Here are the main penalties for spearing in college football:
15-Yard Penalty : Similar to high school rules, a spearing violation results in a 15-yard penalty. This penalty can significantly impact the team’s position on the field, often affecting the momentum and flow of the game.
Ejection and Suspension : In more severe cases, a player may be ejected from the game for spearing, especially if the act is deemed as targeting a defenseless player. The NCAA takes player safety very seriously, and targeting calls are automatically reviewed for accuracy. If upheld, the ejection may also carry a suspension for part or all of the next game.
At the college level, spearing is also prohibited and closely monitored. The NCAA rules classify spearing as part of “targeting” violations, which aim to protect defenseless players from dangerous hits, particularly to the head and neck area. Here are the main penalties for spearing in college football:
The NCAA’s strict rules against spearing reflect the organization’s commitment to reducing head injuries and protecting student-athletes. College football programs invest in educating players on safe tackling techniques and the consequences of targeting fouls, including mandatory film review sessions to analyze proper form and avoid unnecessary penalties.
NFL and Professional Leagues
The NFL has arguably the most comprehensive and strict set of rules regarding spearing and helmet-to-helmet contact. Spearing in the NFL falls under “unnecessary roughness” or “personal foul” penalties, which focus on protecting players from intentional or reckless harm. The NFL enforces these penalties through a variety of methods:
15-Yard Penalty : Spearing violations in the NFL lead to a 15-yard penalty, often resulting in a significant loss of field position and potentially impacting the game’s outcome.
Monetary Fines : NFL players may face monetary fines for spearing or engaging in helmet-first hits, with fines potentially reaching thousands of dollars. These fines are intended to act as a deterrent, reminding players that reckless actions have serious financial consequences.
Suspensions : In cases of repeated or egregious violations, players may be suspended for one or more games. Suspensions serve as a strong measure to maintain player safety and ensure adherence to tackling guidelines.
The NFL has a dedicated Player Safety Advisory Panel that evaluates dangerous hits and enforces penalties, including fines and suspensions, based on the severity of each infraction. In addition, the NFL often reviews these plays to provide further guidance to coaches and players on what constitutes a legal tackle. The league’s efforts to reduce head injuries and promote safer tackling methods reflect its commitment to player health and the longevity of professional careers.
The enforcement of spearing penalties across all levels of football is a reflection of the sport’s increasing commitment to safety. By penalizing players who engage in spearing, football organizations emphasize the importance of safer, controlled tackling techniques that prioritize the health and well-being of athletes.
3. Recognizing Spearing vs. Legal Tackling
Understanding the difference between spearing and legal tackling is crucial for players, coaches, and fans alike. Spearing is often mistaken for aggressive tackling, but it’s actually a dangerous form of contact that football rules explicitly prohibit. Here’s a detailed look at how to distinguish spearing from a legal tackle, along with insights into the signs and techniques that help ensure safe, controlled tackling.
What Defines Spearing?
Spearing involves a player lowering their head and leading with the top of the helmet to initiate contact with an opponent. This technique places the tackler in a head-down position, creating a direct path from the helmet to the opponent’s body. Key characteristics of spearing include:
Head-Down Posture : The tackler’s head is positioned downward, which can place excessive force on the neck and spine upon impact.
Helmet-First Contact : The first point of contact is the top of the helmet, which is both dangerous and illegal in football.
High Risk of Injury : Spearing is considered a major contributor to head, neck, and spinal injuries due to the compression of the spine in a head-down posture.
Coaches and officials often emphasize the need to avoid a head-down position, as it not only increases injury risk but also leads to penalties. Recognizing these signs in practice and game situations can help players avoid making illegal tackles.
Decrease Opponent Points by 18.1% with Atavus
Enhance defense and player safety through data-driven tackle training.
A legal tackle in football is designed to safely bring down the ball carrier without risking injury to either player. Legal tackles typically involve the shoulder or chest as the first point of contact, with the tackler’s head positioned up and to the side. Here are the key elements of a legal tackle:
Head-Up Position : In a safe tackle, the tackler’s head is up, allowing for better control and visibility of the opponent. Keeping the head up helps protect the neck and avoids direct helmet contact.
Shoulder-Led Contact : Instead of using the helmet, legal tackles rely on shoulder-led contact. The shoulder, combined with the arms, provides a solid yet safe base for tackling.
Controlled Form and Balance : A legal tackle involves a balanced stance, where the tackler remains in control throughout the tackle, aiming for the opponent’s torso or legs. This controlled form reduces the chances of high-impact collisions and ensures a clean, effective tackle.
Coaches can reinforce these principles by teaching players to keep their heads up and lead with the shoulder, especially during practice drills. This method not only reduces the likelihood of penalties but also fosters a safer playing environment for everyone on the field.
Tips for Avoiding Spearing and Ensuring Safe Tackling
To help players avoid spearing and master legal tackling, coaches can implement a few essential guidelines:
1. Keep Your Eyes on the Opponent : Players should be trained to keep their eyes on the ball carrier throughout the tackle, which naturally helps to maintain a head-up position.
2. Lead with the Shoulder, Not the Helmet : Remind players to initiate contact with the shoulder rather than the helmet. A shoulder-led tackle allows for a stronger, more controlled tackle without the need for helmet contact.
3. Focus on the Opponent’s Midsection or Legs : Legal tackling techniques typically involve aiming for the midsection or lower body, which provides a secure grip without risking injury. This approach reduces the chances of unnecessary high contact.
4. Practice Form in Controlled Drills : Coaches can use controlled tackling drills to emphasize safe form and positioning. By practicing safe tackling consistently, players can build confidence in their technique, reducing the risk of illegal tackles.
5. Encourage Feedback and Correction : During practice, coaches should give immediate feedback on tackling form and correct any head-down tendencies. Continuous correction helps players internalize safe tackling habits.
By understanding and implementing these tips, players can learn to avoid spearing and focus on controlled, effective tackles. Recognizing the differences between spearing and safe tackling not only improves player performance but also fosters a safer, penalty-free playing environment.
4. The Importance of Safe Tackling Techniques
The push to eliminate spearing highlights the need for safer tackling techniques across all levels of football. By prioritizing safe tackling, coaches can protect their players while still encouraging effective defensive play. Safer techniques, such as the shoulder-led tackle, offer better control and reduce the chances of injuries.
Other safe tackling techniques, like the buckle technique, also focus on controlling the opponent’s lower body to prevent forward movement without the need for dangerous head contact. By practicing and implementing these alternative methods, teams can create a strong defense without compromising player safety.
Spearing is a dangerous, illegal tackling method that can lead to severe injuries. Football’s strict rules against spearing are in place to protect players and ensure a safer game. By understanding what spearing is in football and recognizing the importance of safe tackling methods, coaches and players can work together to prevent harmful practices and foster a better football experience. Coaches are encouraged to train players in techniques that prioritize safety and control, allowing for effective gameplay without the unnecessary risks associated with spearing.
Play Safer, Play Better with Atavus DTA
Access videos, drills, and core concepts for shoulder-led tackling.
1. What is spearing in football, and why is it illegal?
Spearing in football is a tackling method where a player leads with the top of their helmet to make contact with an opponent. It’s illegal because it’s highly dangerous, putting both the tackler and the opponent at risk of serious injuries, including head, neck, and spinal injuries.
2. What are the penalties for spearing in football?
Penalties for spearing vary by level. In high school and college, it results in a 15-yard penalty, and the player may be ejected in severe cases. In the NFL, players can face a 15-yard penalty, fines, and possible suspensions for repeated violations.
3. How is spearing different from a legal tackle?
In a legal tackle, the player leads with the shoulder, keeping the head up to avoid direct helmet contact. Spearing, by contrast, involves a head-down, helmet-first approach, which increases the risk of injury and is therefore illegal.
4. How can coaches help players avoid spearing?
Coaches can implement drills that focus on keeping the head up, leading with the shoulder, and targeting the opponent’s midsection or lower body. Consistent practice and feedback help players develop safe tackling habits that reduce the risk of spearing.
5. Why is the NFL strict about helmet-to-helmet contact and spearing?
The NFL prioritizes player safety, as helmet-to-helmet contact and spearing can lead to severe injuries, including concussions and spinal injuries. The league enforces strict rules to discourage these actions, aiming to create a safer game environment.
