Football is a physically demanding sport where tackling plays a crucial role in defensive strategies. Tackling, when done properly, is an essential and thrilling part of the game. However, not all tackles are safe or legal. Certain tackles, known as illegal tackles, violate the rules and can lead to severe penalties and serious injuries. These illegal tackles pose risks to both the tackler and the tackled player, affecting the game’s flow and player safety.
So, Simply put, an illegal tackle is any form of tackle that violates the game’s safety regulations, usually because it involves dangerous techniques or excessive force. Football’s governing bodies have created strict guidelines to prevent illegal tackles, aiming to protect players while maintaining the game’s competitiveness. This article will explore what constitutes an illegal tackle, the types of illegal tackles, associated penalties, and how players can adopt safer tackling methods to avoid these violations.
1. What is an Illegal Tackle?
An illegal tackle in football is defined as any tackle that involves excessive force, unsafe contact points, or techniques that increase the risk of injury. These tackles often involve targeting vulnerable areas of the opponent's body, such as the head, neck, or legs, or using moves that could result in severe physical harm. Illegal tackles can occur when players lower their heads, use their helmets as weapons, or apply dangerous grips on the opponent’s body.
Key factors that make a tackle illegal include:
Targeting the Head or Neck : Tackles that involve helmet-to-helmet contact or strikes to the neck area are illegal because they increase the risk of head and spinal injuries.
Using Unsafe Techniques : Moves like spearing (leading with the top of the helmet) or facemasking (grabbing the opponent's facemask) can lead to penalties and are considered illegal due to the potential for injury.
Excessive Force or Intent to Harm : Tackles performed with an apparent intent to injure or harm, such as pulling the player backward by the collar, are flagged as illegal.
Understanding what makes a tackle illegal is essential for both players and coaches, as it not only helps prevent injuries but also avoids costly penalties that can affect the outcome of a game.
Decrease Opponent Points by 18.1% with Atavus
Enhance defense and player safety through data-driven tackle training.
Illegal tackles come in various forms, each carrying its own risks and penalties. Here are some of the most common types of illegal tackles in football:
Helmet-to-Helmet Contact
Helmet-to-helmet contact occurs when two players make direct contact with their helmets, typically during a high-speed tackle. This form of tackle is dangerous because it places intense pressure on both players’ heads and necks, increasing the risk of concussions and spinal injuries. Helmet-to-helmet tackles are strictly prohibited at all levels of football due to their high injury risk. Tacklers must keep their heads up and avoid leading with their helmets to prevent these types of collisions.
Why It’s Illegal : Helmet-to-helmet contact violates safety rules and increases the risk of severe head trauma. This type of contact is banned to protect players from concussions, a major concern in modern football.
Penalty : A helmet-to-helmet tackle results in a 15-yard penalty and may lead to player ejections in severe cases, especially at the college and professional levels.
Horse Collar Tackle
The horse collar tackle is a move where a defender grabs the inside back collar or shoulder pads of an opponent and pulls them backward. This sudden, jerking motion places immense stress on the ball carrier’s legs and back, often causing leg and ankle injuries. The horse collar tackle is considered illegal because of the high injury rate associated with it, particularly for lower body injuries like ACL tears.
Why It’s Illegal : The horse collar tackle is prohibited because it often results in dangerous falls and leg injuries. By pulling a player backward, the tackler places the opponent in a vulnerable position, increasing the risk of lower-body trauma.
Penalty : A horse collar tackle incurs a 15-yard penalty and may result in further disciplinary action, especially in professional leagues.
Facemask Tackle
A facemask tackle occurs when a player grabs or pulls the opponent’s facemask while attempting to tackle them. This illegal technique is dangerous because it places excessive force on the opponent’s neck and head, leading to potential neck injuries or whiplash. Facemask tackles are strictly penalized to discourage players from using this high-risk tactic.
Why It’s Illegal : Facemasking is illegal because it endangers the opponent’s neck and spine. Even a slight twist of the facemask can cause serious neck injuries, making it a hazardous practice.
Penalty : Pulling the opponent’s facemask results in a 15-yard penalty and can lead to additional disciplinary action, especially if it appears intentional.
Spearing
Spearing is a tackling technique in which the defender leads with the top of the helmet to make contact with the opponent. This form of tackling places both players at risk because it compresses the spine, increasing the likelihood of severe spinal injuries. Spearing is strictly prohibited as it goes against safe tackling principles and can have life-altering consequences.
Why It’s Illegal : Spearing is illegal because it places the tackler’s head in a vulnerable position, risking neck and spinal injuries for both players.
Penalty : Spearing is penalized with a 15-yard penalty and can lead to player ejections or suspensions in certain leagues, particularly in college and professional football.
These illegal tackles not only jeopardize player safety but also lead to penalties that can impact the game’s momentum and scoring potential. For these reasons, they are closely monitored by officials, and players are encouraged to avoid these risky techniques.
3. Rules and Penalties for Illegal Tackles
Each level of football has specific rules and penalties for illegal tackles to maintain player safety. Here’s a breakdown of how illegal tackles are handled at different levels of play:
High School Football
In high school football, illegal tackles are closely regulated to protect younger players. Coaches emphasize safe tackling techniques, and referees watch carefully for any signs of unsafe contact.
Penalties : Illegal tackles, like facemasking or helmet-to-helmet contact, incur a 15-yard penalty. Repeat offenders or particularly dangerous tackles can result in player ejections.
Educational Focus : High school programs often focus on teaching players how to tackle correctly, aiming to reduce the occurrence of illegal hits and promote safer gameplay.
College Football
The NCAA enforces strict rules against illegal tackling, including a targeting rule designed to penalize dangerous hits on defenseless players.
Penalties : Illegal tackles carry a 15-yard penalty. Targeting fouls, which include helmet-to-helmet contact, are automatically reviewed, and players can be ejected if the call is upheld.
Suspensions : Ejected players may face additional suspensions for part or all of their next game, particularly in cases of repeated violations.
Decrease Opponent Points by 18.1% with Atavus
Enhance defense and player safety through data-driven tackle training.
The NFL takes a strong stance on player safety, implementing strict rules and substantial penalties for illegal tackles. Officials are trained to identify high-risk contact and assess penalties accordingly.
Penalties : Illegal tackles result in a 15-yard penalty and may lead to player fines, with the league imposing substantial fines for repeated or particularly dangerous violations.
Fines and Suspensions : For severe or repeated violations, players can face hefty fines or multi-game suspensions. The NFL reviews all such hits and penalizes players financially as a deterrent to unsafe play.
These penalties are essential for promoting safe play across all levels of football. By enforcing rules and penalties, football organizations aim to reduce the number of illegal tackles and protect the well-being of all players on the field.
4. How Illegal Tackles Impact Player Safety and Gameplay
Illegal tackles have serious consequences that go beyond simply breaking the rules. They endanger players’ health, disrupt the flow of the game, and can change the course of a match. Here’s a closer look at how illegal tackles impact both player safety and gameplay.
Impact on Player Safety
Illegal tackles expose players to a range of injuries, some of which can have long-term consequences. When a player uses an illegal technique—such as leading with the helmet, pulling an opponent backward by the collar, or grabbing the facemask—the risk of injury increases significantly. Here are some ways illegal tackles affect player safety:
Head Injuries and Concussions : Tackles that involve helmet-to-helmet contact or strikes to the head increase the risk of concussions and traumatic brain injuries. Concussions can have long-lasting effects on cognitive function, mood, and physical health, making these types of tackles extremely dangerous.
Neck and Spinal Injuries : Techniques like spearing and horse collar tackles place undue stress on the neck and spine. When players are hit with their heads down or pulled backward suddenly, the spine becomes vulnerable to compression, which can lead to neck fractures, spinal cord injuries, or even paralysis.
Leg and Knee Injuries : Illegal tackles that target the legs, like the horse collar tackle, put players at risk of torn ligaments, particularly in the knees and ankles. Injuries to the ACL, MCL, or Achilles tendon can take months or even years to fully recover from, impacting a player’s career and quality of life.
Whiplash and Facemask-Related Injuries : Facemasking is especially dangerous because even a slight twist or pull on the opponent’s facemask can lead to whiplash or neck strains. This can cause pain, stiffness, and mobility issues in the neck, which may lead to more serious complications if not addressed.
The safety of players is the top priority for football’s governing bodies, which is why these illegal tackles are penalized heavily. Preventing these high-risk actions is crucial for ensuring that players can compete without risking their physical health and longevity in the sport.
Impact on Gameplay
Illegal tackles don’t just impact individual players—they can also significantly affect a team’s performance and strategy during a game. Here’s how:
Field Position and Momentum Shifts : Illegal tackles lead to penalties, which often result in a 15-yard loss for the offending team. This loss of yardage can drastically change the field position, giving the opposing team an advantage that may lead to scoring opportunities or a change in momentum.
Game Flow and Play Stoppage : Illegal tackles cause play stoppages as referees assess penalties and, in some cases, review footage to confirm the foul. These interruptions can disrupt a team’s rhythm and break the natural flow of the game, which can be challenging to recover from, especially in tight matchups.
Player Ejections and Suspensions : In college and professional football, certain illegal tackles, such as targeting, can lead to player ejections or suspensions. Losing a key player due to ejection not only weakens the team’s defense but also forces coaches to adjust their strategy and lineup, often resulting in a less effective performance.
Psychological Impact on Players and Teams : Repeated illegal tackles and penalties can create a tense environment, where players may become hesitant or overly cautious about tackling, fearing penalties or injuries. This can affect a team’s aggressiveness and confidence, impacting overall performance and morale.
The combination of safety risks and gameplay disruptions makes illegal tackles a serious concern in football. By enforcing strict penalties, football authorities aim to deter these dangerous techniques, promoting a cleaner and safer game for all players.
5. Safe Tackling Techniques to Avoid Illegal Tackles
To maintain player safety and avoid penalties, coaches and players are increasingly focusing on safe tackling techniques. These techniques emphasize control, proper form, and the importance of avoiding high-risk areas like the head and neck. Here’s a look at some effective ways players can tackle safely while staying within the rules.
1. Keep the Head Up
One of the most fundamental principles of safe tackling is to keep the head up. Tackling with the head up means that players have their eyes on the opponent and avoid lowering their heads, which can lead to helmet-to-helmet contact or neck injuries.
Why It’s Important : Keeping the head up reduces the risk of head and neck injuries. When players lower their heads, they not only lose sight of their target but also place their necks in a vulnerable position, increasing the risk of spinal compression injuries.
How to Practice : Coaches can use tackling drills that emphasize keeping the head up. For example, players can practice tackling at half-speed while focusing on maintaining an upright head position throughout the motion.
2. Lead with the Shoulder, Not the Helmet
A safe tackle should involve leading with the shoulder rather than the helmet. By using the shoulder as the initial point of contact, players can gain control over the opponent without risking helmet-to-helmet collisions.
Why It’s Important : Leading with the shoulder helps players maintain a safe and balanced tackle, reducing the risk of injury for both the tackler and the opponent.
How to Practice : Coaches often run drills that isolate shoulder contact. Players are instructed to approach their target with their shoulders squared, aiming to initiate contact at the opponent’s midsection, while keeping the head to the side to avoid helmet contact.
3. Wrap and Drive
The “wrap and drive” technique involves wrapping the arms around the opponent while driving forward with the legs. This method allows players to secure the ball carrier without relying on excessive force or high-impact hits.
Why It’s Important : Wrapping and driving provides stability and control, making it difficult for the ball carrier to break free. This technique allows the tackler to use body positioning rather than brute force to bring down the opponent safely.
How to Practice : In this drill, players practice wrapping their arms around a tackling dummy or a teammate while driving forward with their legs. This reinforces the importance of using body leverage to secure the tackle.
4. Aim for the Midsection or Legs
Safe tackles should target the midsection or lower body, as these areas provide a solid target without exposing players to head or neck injuries. Aiming for the legs or torso minimizes the risk of high-impact contact.
Why It’s Important : By avoiding the head and neck, players reduce the likelihood of serious injuries and illegal contact. Targeting the legs or torso also helps players maintain better balance and control.
How to Practice : Coaches can set up tackling drills where players aim for tackling dummies set at the height of an opponent’s midsection or legs. This helps players learn to stay low and focus on these safer target areas.
5. Stay in Control and Avoid Excessive Force
A safe tackle is about control, not aggression. Players should focus on maintaining balance and control rather than delivering high-impact hits. Tackling with excessive force increases the risk of injury and penalties, as it often leads to unsafe contact.
Why It’s Important : Staying in control allows players to execute clean, effective tackles without risking penalties or injuries. It also emphasizes the importance of technique over raw force.
How to Practice : Coaches can implement “control” drills where players practice tackling at reduced speed, focusing on positioning and form rather than force. This drill teaches players the value of control in creating a safe tackle.
6. Practice “Form Tackling” Drills
Form tackling drills are designed to help players internalize safe tackling habits. These drills break down the tackle into specific steps, allowing players to perfect each element of a safe tackle—head up, shoulder-led contact, wrapping, and driving.
Why It’s Important : Form tackling drills allow players to develop muscle memory for safe tackling techniques, making it easier to execute these skills during games.
How to Practice : Coaches lead players through form tackling drills regularly, often using tackle bags or dummies to simulate real opponents. By repeating these drills, players can refine their form and eliminate bad habits that might lead to illegal tackles.
Play Safer, Play Better with Atavus DTA
Access videos, drills, and core concepts for shoulder-led tackling.
An illegal tackle in football is any tackle that violates safety rules by using excessive force, targeting vulnerable areas like the head or neck, or employing dangerous techniques. These tackles can lead to penalties and increase the risk of injury.
2. What are some examples of illegal tackles in football?
Common illegal tackles include helmet-to-helmet contact, horse collar tackles, facemask grabs, and spearing. Each of these tackles carries risks for serious injuries and is penalized to protect players.
3. What penalties are given for illegal tackles?
Illegal tackles generally result in a 15-yard penalty, and players may be ejected for severe or repeated violations. In professional leagues, players may also face fines or suspensions.
4. Why is helmet-to-helmet contact considered illegal?
Helmet-to-helmet contact is illegal because it poses a high risk for concussions and spinal injuries. By avoiding direct helmet contact, players reduce the chances of severe head or neck trauma.
5. How can players avoid making illegal tackles?
Players can avoid illegal tackles by keeping their heads up, leading with their shoulders, and targeting the opponent’s midsection or legs. Practicing safe tackling techniques is essential for maintaining a clean, injury-free game.
